dead

THE DEAD DETECTIVE

Robert L. Wise

Janet Thoma/Thomas Nelson Publishers $13.99pbk

Reviewed by Les Hurst


{short description of image}

We may be washed in the blood of the lamb so that we shall be washed free of our taint of sin. With cash, big wads of it, being imported into the USA, there’s a need that’s somewhat similar. The authorities call it money laundering. And for someone who is not keen to have his laundry subject to close inspection what could be better than to have a bank of one’s own in the far mid-west, under the pure white snow-capped peaks of the Rocky Mountains? In a town that epitomizes small-town America.

Towns like Colorado Springs have pure water and pure detectives; detectives who are the main-stay of their family and their church. Detectives such as Sam Sloan. And detectives such as Sam Sloan have wives who share their souls. Robert L Wise introduced Sam and Vera Sloan in his first mystery, THE EMPTY COFFIN, now Vera has grown. She has been to college and studied criminology - she wants to join the local Police Department and work with her husband. She is so insistent on her desire to work that she seems to be threatening to reject the Biblical injunction to obey her husband.

God, though, does not intend to give Vera the chance to become disobedient. For only a short while after banker George Alexander is found dead in a snow-drift, Sam Sloan first disappears and then is reported dead. Intentionally or not echoing The Blues Brothers, Vera goes on a mission from God to find her husband’s killers.

Vera takes her second choice of job now that she has to pay her way, although luckily that is with the All-Star Detective Agency, which means that she can continue her investigations. This is doubly lucky as the local PD seem at best ignorant of what Sam was doing, and possibly evasive. Before long Vera has to head off for New York City, taking her teenage daughter along with her. Cara can’t be too happy to visit the Big Apple and then find that she is expected to sit in hotel rooms, but she is both a daughter of the church and of her mother and she obeys.

Vera’s criminology classes seem to have involved many hours of practical study of lock-picking and electronic bug planting, which she now puts to good use. In fact, at this point the book almost becomes a techno-thriller, before the final shoot-outs and revelations. Which is quite odd, because elsewhere this is an explicitly Christian novel - where the characters stop and pray in order to gain inspiration for their next action.

In the USA, this Christian sub-genre has an enormous market. I first came across it because my hosts on a visit had been given an out-grown pile of children’s books for their own off-spring and I read a couple, but THE DEAD DETECTIVE is the first adult novel of the type I have read. Unfortunately, and contrary to the earlier examples of clergyman authors like Victor L Whitechurch and Ronald Knox, Bishop Wise’s plotting is not very good, and his attempts to cover the gaps in the plot are perfunctory. There may be many Christians who want to read detective stories written for them, but if this is what comes their way they will be like sheep who look up and are not fed. For over two thousand years critics have condemned the Deus Ex Machina - how much worse is the Deus Ex Minnesota?